Naval Staff Appreciation of Jutland: Difference between revisions
From The Dreadnought Project
Jump to navigationJump to search
Simon Harley (talk | contribs) (Made Changes.) |
Simon Harley (talk | contribs) (Made Changes.) |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
The '''''Naval Staff Appreciation of Jutland''''', C.B. 0938, was a British study of the [[Battle of Jutland]] published under the auspices of the [[Training and Staff Duties Division (Royal Navy)|Training and Staff Duties Division]] of the [[Naval Staff (Royal Navy)|Naval Staff]] in 1922. Prepared by Captain (later Vice-Admiral) [[Kenneth Gilbert Balmain Dewar|Kenneth G. B. Dewar]] and his brother, Captain [[Alfred Charles Dewar|Alfred C. Dewar]], the volume has become notorious for its perceived anti-[[John Rushworth Jellicoe, First Earl Jellicoe|Jellicoe]] (Commander-in-Chief of the [[Grand Fleet]] at Jutland) and pro-[[David Beatty, First Earl Beatty|Beatty]] (Vice-Admiral Commanding, Battle Cruiser Fleet) biases. Printed in a small print run of 100, all copies were recalled by the Admiralty from 1930 onwards for destruction. However, at least four copies survived, and for the centenary of Jutland in 2016 an edition was published, edited by William Schleihauf and Stephen McLaughlin. The publisher, Seaforth, makes the hyperbolic claim that the volume had been "Mentioned in virtually every book on Jutland since, but | The '''''Naval Staff Appreciation of Jutland''''', C.B. 0938, was a British study of the [[Battle of Jutland]] published under the auspices of the [[Training and Staff Duties Division (Royal Navy)|Training and Staff Duties Division]] of the [[Naval Staff (Royal Navy)|Naval Staff]] in 1922. Prepared by Captain (later Vice-Admiral) [[Kenneth Gilbert Balmain Dewar|Kenneth G. B. Dewar]] and his brother, Captain [[Alfred Charles Dewar|Alfred C. Dewar]], the volume has become notorious for its perceived anti-[[John Rushworth Jellicoe, First Earl Jellicoe|Jellicoe]] (Commander-in-Chief of the [[Grand Fleet]] at Jutland) and pro-[[David Beatty, First Earl Beatty|Beatty]] (Vice-Admiral Commanding, Battle Cruiser Fleet) biases. Printed in a small print run of 100, all copies were recalled by the Admiralty from 1930 onwards for destruction.<ref>Beatty to [[Osmond de Beauvoir Brock|Brock]]. Letter of 9 April, 1932. Roskill papers. Churchill Archives Centre. ROSK 3/3.</ref> However, at least four copies survived, and for the centenary of Jutland in 2016 an edition was published, edited by William Schleihauf and Stephen McLaughlin. The publisher, Seaforth, makes the hyperbolic claim that the volume had been "Mentioned in virtually every book on Jutland since [suppression], but unavailable to their authors", ignoring the fact that it was clearly not mentioned in "virtually every book on Jutland", and had been available to historians since the 1960s!<ref>[https://www.pen-and-sword.co.uk/Jutland-The-Naval-Staff-Appreciation-Hardback/p/11692 "Jutland: The Naval Staff Appreciation".] ''Pen & Sword Books''. Accessed 9 December 2024.</ref> | ||
==Surviving Copies== | ==Surviving Copies== | ||
*No. 1. Beatty papers | *No. 1. Beatty papers. National Maritime Museum. BTY/22/9. | ||
*No. 2. [[Roger John Brownlow Keyes, First Baron Keyes|Keyes]] papers | *No. 2. [[Roger John Brownlow Keyes, First Baron Keyes|Keyes]] papers. British Library. Add MS 82490. | ||
*No. 4. [[Stephen Wentworth Roskill|Roskill]] papers | *No. 4. [[Stephen Wentworth Roskill|Roskill]] papers. Churchill Archives Centre. ROSK 3/13. | ||
*No. 7. Jellicoe papers, British Library, Add MS 49042. | *No. 7. Jellicoe papers, British Library, Add MS 49042. | ||
Latest revision as of 17:52, 9 December 2024
The Naval Staff Appreciation of Jutland, C.B. 0938, was a British study of the Battle of Jutland published under the auspices of the Training and Staff Duties Division of the Naval Staff in 1922. Prepared by Captain (later Vice-Admiral) Kenneth G. B. Dewar and his brother, Captain Alfred C. Dewar, the volume has become notorious for its perceived anti-Jellicoe (Commander-in-Chief of the Grand Fleet at Jutland) and pro-Beatty (Vice-Admiral Commanding, Battle Cruiser Fleet) biases. Printed in a small print run of 100, all copies were recalled by the Admiralty from 1930 onwards for destruction.[1] However, at least four copies survived, and for the centenary of Jutland in 2016 an edition was published, edited by William Schleihauf and Stephen McLaughlin. The publisher, Seaforth, makes the hyperbolic claim that the volume had been "Mentioned in virtually every book on Jutland since [suppression], but unavailable to their authors", ignoring the fact that it was clearly not mentioned in "virtually every book on Jutland", and had been available to historians since the 1960s![2]
Surviving Copies
- No. 1. Beatty papers. National Maritime Museum. BTY/22/9.
- No. 2. Keyes papers. British Library. Add MS 82490.
- No. 4. Roskill papers. Churchill Archives Centre. ROSK 3/13.
- No. 7. Jellicoe papers, British Library, Add MS 49042.
Footnotes
- ↑ Beatty to Brock. Letter of 9 April, 1932. Roskill papers. Churchill Archives Centre. ROSK 3/3.
- ↑ "Jutland: The Naval Staff Appreciation". Pen & Sword Books. Accessed 9 December 2024.
Bibliography
- Naval Staff, Training and Staff Duties Division (1922). Naval Staff Appreciation of Jutland.
- Schleihauf, William; McLaughlin, Stephen, eds. (2016). Jutland: The Naval Staff Appreciation. Barnsley: Seaforth. ISBN 978 1 84832 317 9.
